2023 -- Sarah Beth Burns (Kentucky Country Day)
2022 -- Mia Frederick (Sacred Heart Academy)
2021 -- Julia Jardina (Sacred Heart Academy)
2020 -- N/A
2019 -- Ashley Osborne (Ballard High School)
2018 -- Katie Gerber (Eastern High School)
2017 -- Claire Hamilton (Kentucky Country Day)
2016 -- Madison Mitzlaff (Kentucky Country Day)
2015 -- Sydney Flynn (Sacred Heart Academy)
2014 -- Katie Holston (Assumption High School)
2013 -- Emily Scinta (Kentucky Country Day)
2012 -- Jacqueline Anderson (Christian Academy)
2011 -- Hilary Kargl (Sacred Heart Academy)